10
Apr
2026
Legal news
International and European law
2026
Legal news
International and European law
Jurisdiction clause and consumer protection: the implications of the French Court of Cassation’s judgments of 25 March 2026 for Monegasque businesses
FRENCH CASE LAW RELEVANT TO MONACO • Disputes between foreign businesses and their consumer counterparties domiciled in France at the time the action was filed • Consumer contract • Foreign jurisdiction clause • International jurisdiction of French courts
SUMMARY
In two landmark judgments of 25 March 2026 (Appeals Nos. 24-21.422 and 24-21.790, published in the Bulletin and the Report), the First Civil Chamber of the French Court of Cassation established a new rule of French private international law which strengthens the protection of consumers who have entered into contracts with a professional from a third country outside the European Union in the event of a dispute concerning jurisdiction.
In both cases, French consumers had entered into contracts for the opening and operation of credit accounts with Lebanese banks, containing a jurisdiction clause in favour of the courts of Beirut.
Unable to secure the transfer of the funds held in the Lebanese accounts, the plaintiffs brought proceedings against the banks before the French courts of first instance, which declined to exercise their international jurisdiction.
The consumers then appealed to the French Court of Cassation.
The Court of Cassation ruled within the following legal framework:
- On the one hand, the European Union’s private international law (Article 17 of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 December 2012 on jurisdiction, the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters) was inapplicable (the Lebanese bank had not directed its activities towards France, and the dispute did not concern the operation of an establishment or branch in France).
- On the other hand, no provision of French private international law allowed the claimant consumers to challenge the jurisdiction of the courts in Beirut.
The Court of Cassation thus began by noting that, "in accordance with the principles governing French private international law, clauses conferring international jurisdiction are, in principle, valid where the dispute is of an international nature and where the clause does not undermine the mandatory territorial jurisdiction of a French court".
In practice, however, bringing a case before foreign courts located far away may be largely theoretical, given the cost of the proceedings and the procedural difficulties involved in such litigation abroad.
In this context, and with a view to protecting the claimant, the Court of Cassation established a case-law rule by setting a limit on the principle of the validity of foreign jurisdiction clauses: a consumer domiciled in France at the date of the document instituting proceedings cannot be deprived, by a clause designating a foreign court, of the right to bring proceedings before the French courts to rule on the dispute between them and their professional counterparty established abroad.
In the first case (No. 24-21.422), the Court of Cassation dismissed the appeal: the clause conferring jurisdiction on the Lebanese courts in the consumer contract was lawful and enforceable, since the consumers were not domiciled in France on the date of the summons, but in Portugal.
In the second case (No. 24-21.790), the Court of Cassation quashed (on a ground raised of its own motion) the provisions of the Court of Appeal’s judgment which had declared the French courts to lack jurisdiction, since the consumer was domiciled in France on the date of the summons.
IMPACT FOR PROFESSIONALS IN MONACO
Although the businesses involved in these cases were Lebanese banks, the rule on the international jurisdiction of French courts established by the French Court of Cassation applies equally to businesses established in the Principality of Monaco, which, like Lebanon, is a third country outside the European Union.
The new rule established by the Court of Cassation with regard to French (and not European) private international law, which strengthens consumer protection, is general in nature and applicable to Monegasque banks and other professionals in the event of a dispute brought by their consumer counterpart before the French courts.
Thus, a clause designating the courts of Monaco as the competent jurisdiction, although lawful in principle, may be set aside by a French court under French private international law if the other party to the contract is a consumer (non-professional) and is domiciled in France on the date the proceedings are brought.
Point to note: the consumer’s domicile is assessed on the date the proceedings are brought, not on the date the contract was concluded.
Consequently, a customer domiciled in the Principality of Monaco or in another country on the date the consumer contract with a Monegasque professional was concluded may subsequently benefit from the jurisdiction of the French courts if they have relocated to France by the time legal action is taken, even if a clause in the contract assigns jurisdiction to the Monegasque courts.
* * *
Other publications